Best Pizza in Frederick MD | Neapolitan, Coal-Fired & Classic Slices

The best pizza in Frederick MD spans authentic wood-fired Neapolitan at Cugino Forno, brick-oven Italian at Pistarro's, coal-fired pies at Coal Fire, and beloved classics from Ledo, Il Forno, and Pasquale's. Whether you want a blistered Naples-style pie or a family-friendly dine-in slice, here are Frederick's top-rated, verified pizzerias.

8 Best Pizza Places in Frederick MD

1. Cugino Forno Frederick

Address: 1705 N Market St Suite 100, Frederick, MD 21701 · Cuisine: Neapolitan Pizza · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.8/5 (1,167 reviews)

The highest-rated pizzeria in Frederick, Cugino Forno fires authentic Neapolitan pizzas in a blazing wood oven — puffy, charred crusts topped with San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. With more than 1,100 reviews at 4.8★, it sets the standard for serious pizza in the city. A must-visit for Naples-style fans.

2. Pistarro's

Address: 221 N East St, Frederick, MD 21701 · Cuisine: Italian / Brick-Oven Pizza · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.5/5 (1,787 reviews)

With nearly 1,800 reviews, Pistarro's is Frederick's most popular sit-down pizza-and-Italian destination. The brick-oven pizzas come blistered and flavorful, backed by a full menu of pastas and Italian classics and proper table service — ideal for a relaxed pizza dinner with family or friends.

3. Pasquale's Italian Pizza

Address: 8305 River Run Rd, Frederick, MD 21701 · Cuisine: Italian / Pizza · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.5/5 (603 reviews)

A neighborhood favorite at 4.5★, Pasquale's serves classic Italian-American pizza, subs, and pasta with a loyal following. It's the kind of dependable local pizzeria that nails the basics — a solid choice for takeout, delivery, or a casual dine-in meal.

4. Ledo Pizza (Prospect Blvd)

Address: 490 Prospect Blvd, Frederick, MD 21701 · Cuisine: Pizza / Italian · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.4/5 (632 reviews)

A Maryland institution, Ledo is known for its distinctive square, flaky-crust pizza topped edge to edge. The Prospect Blvd location is family-friendly with a full Italian menu and a bar, making it a reliable dine-in or carryout option. A second Ledo on Riverbend Way (4.3★) serves the east side.

5. Il Forno Pizzeria

Address: 1035 W Patrick St, Frederick, MD 21702 · Cuisine: Pizza / Italian · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.3/5 (1,185 reviews)

With nearly 1,200 reviews, Il Forno is a high-volume west-side favorite serving classic pizzas, Italian dishes, and a sports-bar atmosphere. It's a great spot to catch a game with a pie and a pitcher, and the broad menu pleases mixed groups.

6. Coal Fire

Address: 7820 Wormans Mill Rd, Frederick, MD 21701 · Cuisine: Coal-Fired Pizza · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.1/5 (543 reviews)

Coal Fire brings coal-fired pizza to Frederick, using a high-heat coal oven for a crisp, lightly charred crust you won't get from a standard oven. With a full bar and Italian-American menu, it's a sit-down option for diners who want a distinctive crust and a relaxed meal.

7. MOD Pizza

Address: 5265 Buckeystown Pike, Frederick, MD 21704 · Cuisine: Build-Your-Own Pizza (Fast-Casual) · Price: $ · Rating: 4.5/5 (890 reviews)

For a quick, customizable pie, MOD lets you build your own pizza with unlimited toppings at one set price, baked fast in a high-heat oven. At 4.5★ across nearly 900 reviews, it's a popular fast-casual option for families and anyone who wants their pizza exactly their way.

8. Toppings Pizza Company

Address: 5330 New Design Rd, Frederick, MD 21703 · Cuisine: Pizza · Price: $$ · Rating: 4.3/5 (307 reviews)

A solid local pizzeria on the south side, Toppings turns out generously loaded pizzas with a loyal neighborhood following. It's a dependable carryout and delivery choice when you want a classic, well-topped pie close to the Ballenger and New Design Road area.

Planning Your Pizza Night in Frederick

For the best pie, Cugino Forno's wood-fired Neapolitan pizza is the top-rated choice, with Pistarro's close behind for a fuller sit-down Italian experience. Both are near downtown on the north side.

For family dinners, Ledo, Il Forno, and MOD all deliver crowd-pleasing options — Ledo for its iconic square crust, Il Forno for a sports-bar vibe, and MOD for build-your-own customization that keeps kids happy.

For a distinctive crust, Coal Fire's coal oven gives a charred, crisp result worth trying if you've worked through the classics. Between Neapolitan, coal-fired, square-cut, and build-your-own, Frederick covers nearly every pizza style you could want.